Best Shortening Substitutes
What Can I Use Instead of Shortening for Baking?
Use the same amount as the original. 1:1 swap. Adds more flavor but slightly less flakiness in pie crusts due to water content. Excellent in cookies for richness and browning.
Looking for the best Shortening substitute? You're in the right place. We've rounded up 3 reliable Shortening replacements that work in baking — ranked and explained so you can pick the right one for your recipe. Great for when you want to keep things plant-based or avoid dairy. The top pick is Butter — it's the closest match for most recipes. 1:1 swap. Adds more flavor but slightly less flakiness in pie crusts due to water content. Excellent in cookies for richness and browning.
Want exact ratios calculated for your specific recipe? Use the free SubSwap calculator.
Get ratios for Shortening →All Shortening Substitutes (3 options)
1:1 swap. Adds more flavor but slightly less flakiness in pie crusts due to water content. Excellent in cookies for richness and browning.
1:1 swap. Must be solid (refrigerate if needed). Works great in pie crusts and cookies. Use refined coconut oil for neutral taste.
1:1 swap. Traditional choice for superior flakiness in pie crusts and biscuits. Neutral flavor with very high fat content.
As an Amazon Associate, SubSwap earns from qualifying purchases.
Tips for Substituting Shortening
For most recipes, Butter is the best starting point. 1:1 swap. Adds more flavor but slightly less flakiness in pie crusts due to water content. Excellent in cookies for richness and browning. When substituting Shortening in baking, pay close attention to the role it plays — it may affect structure, moisture, flavor, and leavening all at once. Start with a small test batch if the recipe matters. Going plant-based? Coconut oil (solid) is a vegan-friendly option that work well in most recipes. If you're unsure which Shortening substitute to use, think about why the original is in the recipe: flavor, texture, moisture, or binding? Choose the substitute that best matches that function.
Common Questions About Shortening Substitutes
The best substitute for Shortening is Butter. Use the same amount. 1:1 swap. Adds more flavor but slightly less flakiness in pie crusts due to water content. Excellent in cookies for richness and browning.
Butter is the closest substitute for Shortening — use it at a 1:1 ratio for most baking and cooking applications. Adds more flavor but slightly less flakiness in pie crusts due to water content. Excellent in cookies for richness and browning.
Butter is the closest substitute for Shortening — use it at a 1:1 ratio for most baking and cooking applications. Adds more flavor but slightly less flakiness in pie crusts due to water content. Excellent in cookies for richness and browning.
Butter is the closest substitute for Shortening — use it at a 1:1 ratio for most baking and cooking applications. Adds more flavor but slightly less flakiness in pie crusts due to water content. Excellent in cookies for richness and browning.
Butter is the closest substitute for Shortening — use it at a 1:1 ratio for most baking and cooking applications. Adds more flavor but slightly less flakiness in pie crusts due to water content. Excellent in cookies for richness and browning.
In most baking recipes, yes. Butter is the top-rated Shortening substitute for baking. Check the ratio above and note any texture or flavor differences for your specific recipe.
This guide lists 3 Shortening alternatives. The best one depends on your recipe, dietary needs, and what you have on hand — check the substitution cards above for details on each.
Coconut oil (solid) is a great plant-based alternative to Shortening. 1:1 swap. Must be solid (refrigerate if needed). Works great in pie crusts and cookies. Use refined coconut oil for neutral taste.
Also commonly substituted
Related ingredients
New ingredients and substitutions added regularly. Get notified first — no spam.
SubSwap is free. If it saved your recipe, consider buying me a coffee ☕
☕ Buy me a coffee